When it comes to premium running shoes, HOKA and On Running have emerged as two of the most popular contenders. Both offer high-performance sneakers that blend function, comfort, and style—but they do it in very different ways. Whether you’re a seasoned marathoner, a daily walker, or someone looking for all-day comfort and a fashion-forward sneaker, here’s everything you need to know before deciding which brand is best for you.

Before flying out to the Philippines, I carefully packed a small rotation of reliable shoes: the Birkenstock Arizona EVA in Light Rose, On Cloud 6 in Pearl/White, Dolce Vita Nolah Heels in Cafe Multi, and UGG GoldenGlow Sandals in Seasalt. (You can check out my full shoe lineup in my Pack With Me blog.) I figured I’d switch between them depending on the day’s outfit or activity, but to my surprise, one pair stole the show—the UGG GoldenGlow Sandals.